Saturday, 16.11.2024, 12:48

Welcome Passer-by | RSS

Main » 2008 » October » 26 » Present Perfect vs. Past Simple
10:07
Present Perfect vs. Past Simple

1.Present Perfect is frequently used to open conversation, to introduce a new topic. If the conversation continues on the same subject Past Simple refers to definite circumstances (time, causes, purpose, manner) (пример судебного процесса):

e.g.-What have you done? -I’ve done much. I washed my shirt, pressed my pants,…

-Pussy Cat, where have you been? – I’ve been to London to look at the Queen

-Pussy Cat, what did you do there? – I frightened a little mouse under the chair.

Compare: Indefinite article Present Perfect. Definite article Past Simple

e.g. I saw a man. The man was tall.

Even when we’re giving news, if we can’t make a sentence in present about the situation Past Simple is used: e.g. Granny hit me!

Even if there’s no time indication in the initial sentence, Past Simple refers to happenings which are definite in the mind of the speaker. (the situation is well-known to the listener):

e.g. Did you sleep well? Did you hear what he said?

I didn’t understand. Did you have a good trip?

Did you see the accident? I’m sorry I lost my temper.

Did you enjoy the play? (the day after the play)

Have you enjoyed the play? (at the end of the play)


2.Past Simple is used with TODAY, TONIGHT, THIS WEEK (MONTH, YEAR) when they are over. If they are not, Present Perfect is used.

e.g. Did you see him this morning? ( asked in the evening)

Have you seen him this morning? (asked in the same morning)

Sometimes the Place where the action was performed points to a past period:

e.g. Did you see him in the theatre? (when you were at the theatre)


3.Indefinite time adverbs can be used not only with Present Perfect:

e.g. He never touched the piano. (Past Simple)

His room wasn’t yet furnished. (Past Simple)

He noticed that leaves were already beginning to turn yellow. (Past Progressive)

JUST NOW requires Past Simple e.g. I told you just now I didn’t see her there.


4.The period of duration “FOR

-Present Perfect (connection with the present) e.g. He’s lived like this for 15 years.

-Past Simple (belongs to the past) e.g. I worked at school for 5 years, then I decided to become a manager.


Present Perfect is never used (and Past Simple is used instead):


1)When the exact time is indicated: yesterday, 2 hours ago, in 1978, when I did

e.g. They played football yesterday.


2) Historic events: e.g. The battle of Hastings took place in 1066


3) In questions:

-When: e.g. When did you see this man?

-How: e.g. How did you find me?

-Where e.g. Where did they live? Where were you? (fact asking)

!!! Where have you been? (as soon as the person comes back)

Where have you been all this time?

WHO, WHAT, WHAT … FOR, HOW LONG ?


Present Perfect Past Simple

(If reference is made to the present situation) (definite past in the speaker’s mind chain of questions)

What have I done against you? What did he do?

How long did you stay there? How long have you been alone?


Special Uses

1.Now I understand. = теперь я понял

Im told that= Мне сказали, что … (Present Simple instead of

I hear Bob’s bought a new car = Я слышал Боб купил новую машину. Present Perfect)

She is gone = Она уехала.

The lesson is over. = Урок окончен.


2.Long may be used in between Present Perfect with attitudinal, belief-assumption verbs:

e.g. I have long admired his car. He has long though of retiring.


3.Since when is used to inquire about the starting point:

e.g. Since when have you known him?


Present Perfect

Past Simple

The time of the action is not important, only the result. (Present Tense)

e.g. I have bought a car.

It’s important WHEN the action happened (Past Tense fact)

e.g. I bought a car yesterday

Views: 1956 | Added by: enboost | Rating: 0.0/0
Total comments: 1
20.03.2014
1. gyncinorymnJO [Материал]
x9527r-gb, , , , .

Name *:
Email *:
Code *: